medical students not socializing enough?
Check out this post on Dr. Shock’s blog on a recent study that medical students are socially segregated from others.
In my experience, medical training by its nature is very intensive. I wouldn’t want to go to a doctor who wasn’t intensively trained. Most people wouldn’t. That said, the practice of medicine is also a very personal undertaking, the success of which largely depends on one’s ability to connect with patients. This has become quite clear as I have moved through my own training. Moreover, the role of the physician is increasingly spilling over into the world of science where social qualities are also very important for success. What to do? It can be argued that in the last 5-10 years, great progress has been made in “mandating” more social physicians. In the U.S. at least resident (and medical student) work hours have been capped at 80 hrs/wk, which many who have trained through both eras feel is considerably more humane to the training physician. At the same time, there is sometimes an urge to do too much. Most recently in the U.S., there has been some discussion of reducing the resident work hours to ~60 hrs/wk–which many believe will be detrimental to resident training and the continuity of care for the patients. At the end of the day, a career in medicine is not easy. It is hard not to realize this by the end of first year medical school. And social qualities are critical to success as a physician. It is also hard not to realize this by the end of first year medical school. A medical career, and I would say the training as well, necessitates that the student/resident/fellow learn to balance the absolute need for intensive training (these are patients’ lives in our hands) with the need to be a social human being.








November 26th, 2008 at 3:13 am
If you want to have “patients lives in your hand”why is it that 80 hours workweek or more are not prohibited. Anyone with some common sense knows that functioning for such a long time on stretch has consequences for the capabilities, judgment etc for any human being. Pilots know that to. The difference between God and a doctor is that God knows he is not a doctor.
November 26th, 2008 at 7:36 pm
“The difference between God and a doctor is that God knows he is not a doctor.” Ha ha ha!
Humor aside, I did not do residency before the 80 hour work week mandate (I think it was about 5 yrs ago) but I have many friends who did and all say that 100-120 work weeks, while excruciatingly painful, were very beneficial to their medical training. I’m up in the air. I can see both sides of the argument–it is a fine line to walk.